Choose local. Choose independent. Choose Schaefer Agency.

In business since 1952, Schaefer Agency, Inc. has successfully served Colorado Springs, Woodland Park, Manitou Springs, and the Pikes Peak Region for over 60 years.

Being an Independent Insurance Agency, located 4 blocks south of Colorado College, allows us to put your protection and your needs first and foremost. We are able to shop for your important coverage with numerous insurance carriers, so that you receive the best coverage for the best pricing. We represent financially strong companies with the very best reputations for paying claims.

Our experienced, knowledgeable agents are very proud of our hard-earned reputation for pleasant and personalized service whenever you have a question or concern. We are big enough to handle your needs yet small enough to care about you. Above all, Schaefer Agency is an agency that you can trust to put you first.


Need an insurance quote? Get in touch!

Access quotes from Colorado's most trusted insurance carriers. It’s comparison shopping at the click of a mouse.

Temporary Office Closure

As events evolve rapidly across the U.S. in regards to the COVID-19 coronavirus, we at The Schaefer Agency take the safety of our clients and staff very seriously.

We will temporarily be closing the office and working remotely to help maintain the health and well-being of every client and staff member.

While we are away and unable to answer the phone please leave a voicemail and we will be checking these and returning phone calls every 15 minutes.

Should there be an instance in which we need to meet in person we will address this on a case by case basis.

We are approaching the situation with an abundance of optimistic caution. Thank you for your continued business.